In the formal healthcare system, if you want to know how much was spent on treatment by a patient, you will usually find a record for it. On most occasions but not always, someone had to provide a bill and receive a payment. But if you want to know what happened to the people receiving care afterwards, you are unlikely to find any records.

I started noticing this at a health policy conference in Bengaluru this June. I had gone expecting three days of arguments about health systems and policy, robust discussions on how we finance, organise, and make healthcare better. I had not expected one of the first questions to be something as basic as whether we knew what people were dying of.

Counting deaths, not their causes

A little bit of digging led me to a startling finding.

India registered 86.5 lakh deaths in 2022. A medically certified cause was recorded for 19.3 lakh of them, only about 22 per cent. Our country had a glaring problem, and that question at the conference was nontrivial. We are relatively better at recording that someone died, but not what they died of.

That does not mean we have no idea what Indians are dying from; we just have another system for this. A sample of deaths is investigated by verbal autopsy, where trained investigators ask families about the symptoms and circumstances around a death. This is how we have been able to estimate, at the population level, that non-communicable diseases, like heart attacks and cancers, now account for more deaths in India than infectious ones like diarrhoea and pneumonia. This method is useful for understanding the cause of death at the state or country level.

The problem becomes clear when you come down to the district-level. A district health officer can tell you how many people died in their district last year, but they will not be able to explain the cause of these deaths reliably, as only state-level data is available through surveys.

They do have other district-level data at their disposal. The National Family Health Survey gives them figures on child deaths, immunisation, and blood pressure among others. But none of that tells them what the deaths in their district were from, or whether that pattern looks different from the state they are being averaged into.

Go below the district level, and the problem gets more concrete. Dr. John Oommen, who has spent nearly four decades working with Adivasi communities in Odisha, describes villages where the health system barely has a presence. In an interview with IDR, he says: “If your village has 100 houses, an Auxiliary Nurse Midwife (ANM) will visit. If there are 50 houses, an anganwadi worker will come. But if a village has only 10 houses, nobody comes. You're not on the radar, not for the system. And the reality is that many tribal villages are this size. And so, the highest number of deaths occur in villages with 10-20 houses.”